Courageous Conversations Start Long Before the Difficult ConversationWhy trust, connection and human presence are becoming essential leadership capabilities. We talk a lot about the importance of communication in leadership. Yet I wonder whether we're spending enough time thinking about the relationships that underpin those conversations. I recently watched a video shared by Steven Bartlett that beautifully illustrated how human connection is built, and how easily it can be broken. Two people connect through a conversation holding a piece of string which is taunt. Then one picks up their phone it slackens. Their attention shifts. The connection weakens. Even having a phone sitting on the table can change the dynamic. It made me reflect on something I've been exploring in my recent Courageous Conversations workshops with managers. How can we expect managers to have honest, courageous conversations when we haven'tgiven them the time or opportunity to build the trust and relationships that make thoseconversations possible?The changing reality of managing peopleManaging people has never been straightforward, but the expectations placed on managers today are considerable. They're expected to deliver results, manage performance, coach and develop their teams, support wellbeing, navigate interpersonal challenges, manage flexibility and create psychologically safe workplaces. At times, they're expected to be a coach, counsellor, technical expert, mediator and problem-solver, all while delivering their own work. Add hybrid working, constant digital communication, increasing workloads and evolving workplace expectations, and the complexity grows. The boundaries between supporting employees, respecting individual needs and holding people accountable can feel increasingly difficult to navigate. Employment obligations, flexible working arrangements, the right to disconnect and psychological safety are all important aspects of a contemporary workplace. But managers need to understand what these mean in practice, including what they can reasonably expect, how to communicate those expectations and how to address concerns when things aren't working. Psychological safety doesn't mean avoiding uncomfortable conversations. It means creatingan environment where people can speak honestly, respectfully challenge one another andaddress issues without fear of humiliation or retaliation.And that includes conversations about performance, behavior and accountability. Coaching is comfortable. Courageous conversations are harder. In my recent workshops, we explored the difference between coaching conversations and courageous conversations. Most managers are relatively comfortable having everyday coaching conversations. Recognizing good work. Offering encouragement. Brainstorming ideas. Helping someone work through a challenge. Providing suggestions. These conversations are generally positive. They build confidence and strengthen relationships. They're what I sometimes think of as filling someone's cup. But what happens when the conversation changes? When someone's behavior isn't aligned with organizational values? When performance falls below expectations? When agreed responsibilities aren't being fulfilled? Or when a manager needs to challenge someone's approach, rather than simply encourage them? Suddenly, the conversation feels different. Managers worry about how their feedback will be received. Will the employee become defensive? Will they feel criticized? Will the conversation damage the relationship? Could it lead to a complaint or misunderstanding? Employees, too, may experience feedback as a threat, particularly when they don't feel understood, supported or respected. And so, too often, the conversation is delayed or avoided. Yet avoiding these conversations rarely makes the underlying issues disappear. Trust is built before we need it One of the most important lessons from leadership development is that trust cannot suddenly be manufactured when a difficult conversation becomes necessary. It's built through the everyday interactions that come before it. The informal check-in. The question asked with genuine curiosity. The time spent listening. The follow-through on a commitment. The willingness to understand someone's perspective. These small moments create the foundation for more challenging conversations. When trust exists, feedback is more likely to be understood as an opportunity to improve, rather than a personal attack. When trust is absent, even well-intentioned feedback can be interpreted negatively. The quality of our difficult conversations often depends on the quality of the relationshipswe've built before them.Are we giving managers enough time to lead? This is where I believe organization's need to reflect. We talk about the importance of leadership, engagement, psychological safety and high-performing teams. But are we genuinely creating the conditions for managers to build these things? Or have we filled their calendars with meetings, reporting, operational demands and competing priorities, leaving little time for meaningful conversations? Hybrid working has added another layer. The spontaneous conversations that once happened in corridors, over coffee or between meetings are less frequent for many teams. More communication happens through email, messaging platforms and virtual meetings. These tools offer enormous benefits, but they also remove many of the cues that help us understand one another. Tone, body language, facial expressions and context can be lost or misinterpreted. A short message intended to be efficient can feel dismissive. A delayed response can be interpreted as disengagement. An email meant to clarify something can unintentionally create tension. And when we're distracted by notifications, multitasking during meetings or checking our phones while someone is speaking, we're sending another message, whether we intend to or not. You're not receiving my full attention. In an increasingly digital workplace, being clear, present and intentional in our communication matters more than ever. The leadership challenge isn't just about skillsOf course, managers need practical skills and frameworks to navigate difficult conversations. They need to know how to prepare, describe concerns objectively, listen, ask questions, clarify expectations and agree on next steps. But frameworks alone aren't enough. We also need to create workplaces where managers have the capacity, confidence and organizational support to lead people well. That means recognizing that relationship-building isn't something managers do when they've finished their 'real work'. Building trust, developing people and having meaningful conversations are the real work ofleadership.And organization's need to value that time accordingly. A question worth asking As we increasingly turn to technology and AI to improve productivity and efficiency, perhaps we should also ask what we're doing with the time we save. Are we simply filling it with more tasks and transactions? Or are we reinvesting some of it in the human connections that help people and organizations thrive? Because technology can help us communicate faster. But it cannot replace the human work of building trust, understanding one another and having the conversations that matter. Courageous conversations don't begin when we raise a difficult issue. They begin in theeveryday moments when we choose to be present, listen and build trust.And perhaps that's where we need to invest more of our attention. Are you giving your managers the time and support to build meaningful relationships with their teams, or are you expecting them to lead through a calendar full of transactions? Kelly Magowan is an executive coach, leadership strategist and the creator of The Level Up Program™. Through immersive and human-centered learning experiences, she helps leaders and teams strengthen self-awareness, communication, adaptability and the human capabilities needed to navigate changing workplaces. Learn more about Kelly's work at Diversitas Consultingand explore The Level Up Program. |
Director | XR Program Designer & Facilitator | The Level Up Program™ Empowering Leaders, Teams, Organizations to Thrive through XR & AI, Training & Coaching I Executive & Leadership Coach
Are we becoming more productive, but less human? AI, our phones and what we risk losing in the pursuit of efficiency. Like so many of us, I have been thinking a lot lately about our relationship with technology. I recently shared a LinkedIn post about AI and how, as I use it more, I sometimes find myself questioning where my own thinking ends and AI begins. Interestingly after my post and thoughts I have discovered it seems listening to some recent CEOs from AI companies such as Mustafa...
Executive News Supporting Executives & Aspiring Executives to Grow, Lead & Thrive www.diversitas.com.au Welcome Celebration - Reflection - Career Momentum As we close out 2025, it’s the ideal moment to pause, acknowledge your wins, and honour the growth you’ve driven — both individually and with your teams. The final quarter naturally brings a shift in pace, creating space to reflect on career achievements, reset intentions, and architect the momentum you want to carry into 2026. This month’s...
Executive News Supporting Executives & Aspiring Executives to Grow, Lead & Thrive www.diversitas.com.au Welcome This month in October, we’re diving into the leadership edge that matters most right now: EQ in the age of AI, the role of play in high-performing teams, and practical steps to launch your Board career. You’ll also find an end-of-year team experience that blends fun with insight. Articles & Resources Crafting a Winning Board CV: Key Strategies Writing a Board CV isn’t about adding...